I went through all your past posts – including your last thread where I think I gave you your boilerplate for progress...
I’m not sure what you are looking for...
In your last thread you state you already told his wife by sending her a letter. At that time this wife never mentioned an open marriage and you say her husband convinced her this was not an affair. Issues that wouldn’t be there had this been an open marriage.
There was another man (the babysitting situation) with a suspicious and jealous wife, so it’s hardly an open marriage if his wife is suspicious and jealous.
What OM are we talking about here? Her manager, the babysitter-service buyer, or a new third OM?
We recommend exposure for a couple of reasons. One being the moral factor of letting the OP spouse be aware of what’s going on, the other being that in MOST instances this kills the affair. In your instance it does neither. So... let it go.
Trying to get your wife to be faithful by influencing the other stakeholders (OM wife(s)) would be like trying to get her sober by asking Smirnoff not to sell vodka in your town. It won’t work.
--
I’m not into poly or open marriage or swinging or any of that, but there are couples that do it and many successfully. As a rule they do so by having firm ground-rules in place. With open marriages it’s generally that there is no or limited emotional connection, both partners aware of the others "events", often it has to be a no-strings/hassle involved (like – the OP needs to be single or in an open marriage). This might not apply in your situation, but it does make me doubt the open marriage part...
But the OP and their spouse(es?) aren’t the issue. The issue is that your wife is cheating.
--
Your wife is in an open affair. The only thing that’s unclear is the extent.
To use the drinking comparison again: If your wife was an alcoholic and had a past where she got blacked-out drunk and caused scenes then what she’s offering now is that she still goes to the bar, still has one beer and still wishing for that euphoria of a second, third and fourth drink. It’s more-or-less only a question of time when she’s going to be causing a scene at the bar.
You on the other hand doubt the stories the others at the bar tell you. You think the police report might be exaggerated, or that maybe she wasn’t the one that broke the beer-glass in the bartenders face. You want all the witnesses to confirm everything, you want to be there when and if it happens again.
Only... when it happens again it might be too late. I suggest you go back to my suggestion in your last thread and start getting out of infidelity, rather than focus on understanding how deep in it your marriage really is.
[This message edited by SI Staff at 2:43 PM, Wednesday, April 16th]